Close Menu
The London News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Vimeo
    The London News
    Subscribe Login
    • Tech
    • Fitness & Health
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Food & Drink
    • Lifestyle
    The London News
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertise With Us
    Home»Lifestyle»Workers are punished for ignoring AI advice – even when the outcome is better
    Lifestyle

    Workers are punished for ignoring AI advice – even when the outcome is better

    EditorBy Editor1 January 2025Updated:1 January 2025No Comments3 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Workers are punished for ignoring AI recommendations and making their own decisions, even if the decision is justified and leads to a better outcome, according to new research by Frankfurt School of Finance and Management and ESMT Berlin.

    In fact, the researchers found that managers punished workers, through lower bonus payments, when they swayed from AI recommendations, clearly showing that in many organisations there is an over-reliance on AI and algorithms.

    These findings come from research by Prof Dr Mirko Kremer, Professor of Supply Chain Management at the Frankfurt School, Francis De Véricourt, Academic Director of the Institute for Deep Tech Innovation (DEEP) at ESMT Berlin, and Hossein Nikpayam, a Postdoc in Operations Management at ESMT Berlin and Frankfurt School.

    The researchers wanted to examine how organisations are implementing AI-based systems to improve and speed up work processes, and the unintended consequences that come with regularly delegating tasks to AI and algorithms.

    To do so, the researchers created a controlled lab experiment where a model creates an AI recommendation and decision-makers needed to decide whether to continue with the AI recommendation or use their human judgement to make a different decision. Managers then pay decision-makers a bonus based on their decision – in some instances managers can see all recommendations, just one or none.

    The results revealed a huge over-reliance on AI-supported systems when decision-makers are using them for recommendations. Managers wanted decision-makers to follow the advice of the AI algorithms, even if this advice is sub-par or less likely to have a positive outcome.

    When decision-makers swayed from the AI recommendations, despite their human knowledge actually leading to a better decision and outcome, they were still punished by managers for not following the algorithm’s advice, and received lower bonus payments despite putting more effort and critical thinking into making the right decision.

    This behaviour from managers causes employees to overly rely on the AI’s recommendations and ignore their own expertise and intuition, even when these are superior to the AI, out of fear of being punished. The consequence of this is that decision-making is not improved under AI algorithms – it actually deteriorates – and workers simply shift all decision-making power to an algorithm or risk negative personal consequences.

    “While businesses across industries are racing to implement AI algorithms to enhance efficiency and decision-making, it’s crucial to remember that these systems should not be relied upon completely,” says Dr Kremer. “It is important to remember that human expertise remains essential to navigate complexities, make nuanced judgments, and adapt to unexpected situations that AI might miss – especially in in sectors like healthcare, aviation or autonomous vehicles, where the implications of blindly following AI advice can have huge implications.”

    The researchers say that this research has important insights for organisations who are wanting to integrate AI systems into their decision-making processes. Firstly, transparency is crucial – managers need to be able to understand and evaluate the AI’s recommendations to make informed decisions.

    Secondly, there should be a higher level of trust in human expertise. Organisations should emphasise the importance of human expertise and intuition and encourage employees to deviate from AI recommendations if they do not agree with their own judgment.

    And finally, clear communication structures are needed in organisations, so that employees can freely express their concerns and experiences with AI systems.

    Featured Photo by Andrew Neel on Unsplash.

    • Editor
      Editor
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
    Previous ArticleNew cyber security and business resilience policy centre
    Next Article Badiani and Slitti Unite to Bring the Best of Italian Gelato and Chocolate to Customers in London.
    Editor
    • Website

    Related Posts

    StayCotswold Map Reveals the Best Dog Walks in the Cotswolds

    11 September 2025

    Dorset Cottage Holidays Teams Up with Brakeburn and Isle of Purbeck Golf Club to Launch the Ultimate Autumn Dorset Getaway

    11 September 2025

    Barking mad Londoners are giving their pampered pooches the A-list treatment.

    10 September 2025

    Burning Man 2025: As the Dust Settles, a Short Film Captures the Spirit for Those Who Couldn’t Be There

    10 September 2025
    Our Picks

    StayCotswold Map Reveals the Best Dog Walks in the Cotswolds

    11 September 2025

    Dorset Cottage Holidays Teams Up with Brakeburn and Isle of Purbeck Golf Club to Launch the Ultimate Autumn Dorset Getaway

    11 September 2025

    Etpl appoints Oakvale Capital as exclusive investment banker to lead capital raise and growth strategy

    11 September 2025

    Discover Wellness-Essary: The Female-Founded App Transforming Wellbeing

    10 September 2025
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    About Us
    About Us

    We're accepting new partnerships right now.

    Email Us: [email protected]

    Our Picks

    Beat the classroom bugs

    2 September 2025

    London’s Biggest Bowie Lookalike Competition Announced by ZIGGYFEST

    29 August 2025

    Miracle Man Ismail Crosses the Finish Line in Walk2Help challenge for Forget Me Not Hospice

    27 August 2025
    Subscribe to Updates

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from The London News

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertise With Us
    © 2025 by The London News.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Sign In or Register

    Welcome Back!

    Login below or Register Now.

    Lost password?

    Register Now!

    Already registered? Login.

    A password will be e-mailed to you.