Online sellers: lower fees can mean a dearer order

    Small online sellers choosing a marketplace or website should compare the cost of a completed order before committing their December selling budget.

    Harvey Dhillon - Zmartly
    Harvey Dhillon - Zmartly

    18 November 2026 · 3 min read

    Two women pack items into cardboard boxes filled with pink shredded paper, with a laptop at the edge of the table

    Small online sellers choosing between a marketplace and their own website should compare what one completed order leaves after the costs of attracting the buyer and fulfilling the sale. A lower platform fee can be outweighed by the advertising, delivery, returns and work needed to secure and fulfil that sale.

    The useful comparison starts with the price a customer will actually pay on each channel. Use the same product and delivery promise, then follow the order from the first advert to the last customer message.

    A website needs a route for buyers to find it. A marketplace listing also needs testing: being available to buy does not establish that anyone will buy. Put the proposed advertising spend beside each option, rather than treating one route as automatically free of marketing costs.

    Include payment processing separately where it is charged separately. Check what each fee already covers so that the same cost does not appear twice. Add packaging and delivery, even when the customer sees the word "free". The parcel has yet to learn that trick.

    Keep a line for returns and a line for your time. Packing, answering questions and sorting delivery problems belong in the decision, even when you do the work yourself.

    Monthly subscriptions need a place too. Divide them across a cautious estimate of completed orders. A calculation built on hoped-for sales is a forecast, not evidence that a channel is cheap.

    The lower fee loses in this illustration

    Illustration, not a real client. Assume a small seller compares the same £40 order on a marketplace and its own website. These are invented planning amounts, not any platform's prices or a calculation of taxable profit.

    For either route, assume £12 for the product, £4 for packaging and delivery, £2 allocated for the cost of returns across orders, and £3 as a planning value for the owner's time. Those common costs total £21.

    • Marketplace: £5 platform fee, £1 payment processing, £2 advertising and £1 allocated monthly subscription cost. Channel costs total £9. Total costs are £30, leaving £10 from the £40 order.

    • Own website: £1 platform fee, £1 payment processing, £8 advertising and £2 allocated monthly subscription cost. Channel costs total £12. Total costs are £33, leaving £7 from the £40 order.

    The website saves £4 on the platform fee. But advertising costs £6 more and the subscription allocation costs £1 more, leaving it £3 behind overall.

    The lesson is to identify which assumption decides the result. Here, the cost of finding a buyer outweighs the fee saving. Replace every assumption with your own evidence before choosing.

    Neither remainder is take-home profit. Other business overheads and tax are outside this comparison, while the allowance for the owner's time is a decision-making estimate. Its purpose is to stop unpaid hours disappearing from the choice.

    A small trial tests the route before December

    Use a small trial to replace guesses with records. Keep the product and delivery offer comparable, but record the actual selling price on each channel. A higher price only belongs in your forecast once buyers have shown they will pay it.

    1. Record sales, refunds and each separate charge. Retain the invoices and reports that explain the amounts.

    2. For each channel, divide total trial advertising spend by all completed orders in that trial. Include spending that produced no sale. If no orders complete, record the spend and zero orders separately.

    3. Track time spent on listings, customer questions, packing and problems. Apply the same value to your time on both channels.

    4. Allow for returns before declaring a winner. Record refunds consistently and avoid counting the same loss twice.

    5. Compare the remainder per order alongside the number of orders you can realistically attract and fulfil.

    Keep this commercial comparison separate from your tax calculation. HM Revenue and Customs' guidance on trading income defines gross income before allowances or expenses and explains that claiming the trading allowance prevents deducting other expenses or allowances.

    If you use an ecommerce accounting service, ask for a channel comparison that shows the underlying charges and assumptions. A single combined sales total cannot answer which route deserves the next advertising pound.

    Before committing December's selling budget, complete the comparison for a product you intend to promote. Set a spending limit and a review date for the trial before the first advert runs.

    About the author

    Harvey Dhillon is Founder and CEO of Zmartly, an accountancy firm for ecommerce sellers. He grew up in West London and began his career in finance at Barclays, in investment banking and wealth management, before going full-time on Zmartly in 2020.

    Featured photo by Pavel Danilyuk on Pexels.

    ZmartlyHarvey Dhillononline sellersecommercemarketplacesbusiness costspricingonline shops
    Harvey Dhillon - Zmartly
    Harvey Dhillon - Zmartly

    Contributor at The London News