One in four online shoppers admits to returning a different item, new research reveals

    E-commerce, retail, returns, reverse logistics.

    Guest Post

    20 November 2026 · 2 min read

    Return package being checked and logged.

    A study by ecommerce operations platform Loop has found that 26% of UK online shoppers have substituted the original product with something else when making a return, while almost a third (31%) admit to sometimes or often giving an untruthful reason to secure a refund or exchange.

    The findings highlight the growing challenge facing retailers as they head into one of the busiest shopping periods of the year, with 82% of UK retail decision-makers surveyed saying returns fraud and abuse is already a problem for their business.

    The research, conducted independently by Sapio Research among 1,000 UK consumers and 200 retail decision-makers, also found that 14% of shoppers have returned clothing after wearing it briefly, giving a different reason for the return.

    For retailers, the problem extends beyond shoppers changing their minds. More than half (58%) say they commonly encounter false claims that items have not arrived or have been delivered damaged. Meanwhile, 41% regularly encounter customers returning different or damaged products, and a third (33%) report cases of 'wardrobing' – where customers wear clothing before returning it.

    The timing is particularly challenging for retailers, with Black Friday and Cyber Monday expected to drive significant online trading activity, followed by the Christmas shopping season and the subsequent wave of returns.

    Retailers are already operating in a difficult trading environment. IMRG's review of the 2025 eight-day Black Friday trading period recorded a 1.2% year-on-year fall in UK online retail revenue, with clothing retailers experiencing a 7.3% decline. More recently, Office for National Statistics figures showed that retail sales volumes fell by 0.4% in September compared with the previous month.

    Samir Kamnani, Senior International Programme Manager at Loop, said: "Black Friday and Christmas sales figures only tell half the story. A sale that looks like a win at checkout can become a loss if a dishonest refund claim goes through or the wrong item comes back to the warehouse. As it does every year, the peak shopping period will trigger a surge in returns, so retailers face the challenge of identifying fraudulent claims without slowing down refunds for genuine customers."

    More than half (56%) of retailers surveyed currently rely on manual reviews to tackle returns fraud, while 29% use return fees and 27% impose restrictions on customers.

    However, taking a tougher approach to returns comes with its own risks. More than half (55%) of UK shoppers surveyed said they had either stopped shopping with an online fashion brand or abandoned a purchase because of its returns policy.

    Kamnani added: "Increasingly, technology is being used to assess the risk of individual returns, flagging suspicious activity and delaying refunds in higher-risk cases until items have been received and inspected, while allowing legitimate returns to be processed as normal.

    "However, treating every customer with suspicion is not the answer. Retailers need to identify abuse while keeping returns easy for honest shoppers. Otherwise, they risk losing both the money and the customer."

    The findings underline the balancing act facing retailers this peak season: protecting margins against increasingly sophisticated returns abuse without making the shopping and returns experience more difficult for genuine customers.

    Guest Post

    Contributor at The London News