eBay resellers: the Flat Rate Scheme or the margin scheme
A VAT-registered eBay reseller cannot use the Flat Rate Scheme and the margin scheme together. Where the two break even, and the 16.5 per cent trap.

22 November 2026 · 4 min read

An eBay reseller who registers for VAT has two simpler ways to work it out, and has to pick one. The margin scheme charges VAT on the profit on each second-hand item. The Flat Rate Scheme charges a fixed percentage of everything you take. HMRC's rules say you cannot join the Flat Rate Scheme while you use the margin scheme, so the choice is worth making with real numbers.
Two ways to pay VAT on the same sale
The margin scheme charges VAT at one-sixth of the difference between what you paid for an item and what you sold it for. It suits stock bought from private sellers, because it cannot be used on anything you were charged VAT on when you bought it.
The Flat Rate Scheme charges a fixed percentage of your turnover, VAT included, and in return you reclaim almost nothing on what you buy. You can join if your VAT turnover is £150,000 or less, excluding VAT. A general retailer pays 7.5 per cent, with 1 per cent off in the first year of VAT registration.
Where the two meet
On the margin scheme, VAT is a sixth of the margin on each item. On the Flat Rate Scheme at 7.5 per cent, it is 7.5 per cent of the selling price. Leaving overheads aside, the two cost the same when your margin is 45 per cent of the price. Below that, the margin scheme costs less. Above it, the flat rate can win.
Illustration, not a real client. Dev buys used film cameras and retro games consoles from private sellers and car boot sales, and sells them on eBay from Walthamstow. He is registered for VAT and sells £100,000 a year.
If the items he sells cost him £65,000, his margin is £35,000 and the margin scheme VAT is £5,833. On the Flat Rate Scheme he would pay £7,500, or £6,500 in his first year.
If they cost him £40,000, his margin is £60,000 and the margin scheme VAT is £10,000. The flat rate is still £7,500.
Two things tilt it further. On the margin scheme, an item sold for less than it cost carries no VAT, though the loss cannot be set against other sales. On the Flat Rate Scheme, the percentage applies to every sale, loss-makers included. And the margin scheme lets him reclaim VAT on overheads such as packaging and fees that carry VAT, which the flat rate does not.
The limited cost trap
The flat rate has a second rate for businesses that buy very few goods. Under VAT Notice 733, you are a limited cost business, and pay 16.5 per cent whatever your trade, if what you spend on goods in a VAT period is under 2 per cent of your flat rate turnover, or over 2 per cent but under £1,000 a year. On quarterly returns, that is £250 a quarter.
A reseller buying stock every quarter usually passes. The test is run every return, though. Say Dev were on the flat rate and had a quiet quarter, selling £20,000 of stock he bought earlier and buying only £300 of new stock. That is over £250 but under 2 per cent of his turnover, so the quarter is at 16.5 per cent: £3,300. On the margin scheme, if those items cost him £11,000, the VAT would be £1,500.
Choosing between them
HMRC's notice says that if you sell a significant proportion of second-hand goods under the margin scheme, the Flat Rate Scheme "will be of limited value to your business", because it taxes the total received rather than the margin. The margin scheme asks more of you in return. HMRC says you must have invoices for each item that meet the scheme's own requirements, which are not the same as the normal VAT invoice rules, and a record of what each item cost and sold for.
For most resellers I would start from the margin scheme and only move if a year of real numbers says the flat rate is cheaper. Work out your average margin, see how evenly you buy stock across the year, and be honest about whether you will keep the records up to date.
The Budget on 28 October answered one question for resellers. When marketplaces are due to start collecting VAT on UK sellers' sales from October 2027, second-hand goods are set to be left out, so the margin scheme should keep working on eBay. The law is still to come, and the government has not yet said how the Flat Rate Scheme will work alongside those rules.
Leave the Flat Rate Scheme and you must wait 12 months to rejoin, so the choice is worth getting right first time. How we set up VAT and the books for eBay resellers shows how platform reports and stock records come together, and ecommerce accounting services for resellers cover the returns under whichever scheme you choose. Run the comparison on your last four quarters before your next return is due.
About the author
Harvey Dhillon is Founder and CEO of Zmartly, an accountancy firm for ecommerce sellers. He grew up in West London and began his career in finance at Barclays, in investment banking and wealth management, before going full-time on Zmartly in 2020.
Featured photo by Wallace Chuck on Pexels.

Contributor at The London News