Box shifting is dead in London. Empty Property Rates avoidance is not.

    Shaylesh Patel, CEO and Founder of ASTOP

    20 November 2026 · 2 min read

    Box shifting is dead in London. Empty Property Rates avoidance is not.

    London’s councils have won two big battles against business rates avoidance in recent months. The Court of Appeal ruled in City of London v 48th Street Holdings that box shifting, placing items in an empty building purely to reset the empty rates clock, is not lawful occupation. Then the Budget committed the Government to a General Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR) for business rates.

    Both are welcome, but neither is going to be the end of the empty property business rates avoidance. London still loses around £75 million a year to rates avoidance. That is enough to fund three secondary schools, build 500 council houses, or provide for 37,000 hospital beds, every year, in the capital alone.

    The direction of travel has been clear for some time. Councils and central government grew tired of an empty rates avoidance industry built largely by advisers selling questionable tactics to landlords. ASTOP was invited to assist the Treasury Committee in the first quarter of 2026 as an unconflicted voice. Like the social media companies that were given the chance to self-regulate and did not take it, the property sector has now had the rules taken out of its hands.

    But there is a gap between a GAAR being announced and a GAAR being in force, and unethical actors will not wait. The end of box shifting has already sent people looking for the next scheme, and three patterns are worth watching.

    First, former staff of box shifting operations are setting up new websites and structures, pitching themselves as experienced and ethical brokers of space for community organisations. Some of these people have spent a decade diverting millions of square feet away from charities and cash-strapped councils. Their new story deserves scrutiny.

    Second, more rating agencies are suddenly discovering a passion for the charity sector, and some have been box shifting internally for asset managers. Landlords should ask whether advice was ever truly unconflicted, and whether charity-led options would have delivered more financial and social value than the arrangement they were sold.

    Third, there is a scheme I expect to end up in front of a judge. A token donation of goods goes into a large empty space on day one, and a charity is grateful for it. On day two, the goods are moved to another site, the first space is declared empty and claims full relief, and the goods return just before the property goes back to the landlord. The council collects a fraction of what it should, and the charity never really gets the space.

    Government has the tools to deal with all of this if it uses them well. The GAAR must be drafted with these pivots in mind. Landlords should be legally required to report occupancy changes immediately, because late reporting lets schemes take hold before councils can act. And unregulated business rates agents need a mandatory code of conduct backed by penalties.

    London has shown that avoidance can be beaten. Let’s not take another decade to finish the job.

    Charity
    Shaylesh Patel, CEO and Founder of ASTOP

    Contributor at The London News